Overblown, Stale, Grainy. It Can Only Mean One Thing….

13 Jul

Okay so before I start this I should probably point out that, you know, blogs are for expressing individual opinions and that no opinion expressed on there wil reperesent the way everyone thinks. I’m saying this because I expect a little bit of backlash from this post. Well, not really because I know you’re all nice and that any criticism is constructive.

But really, do we really need a new project from this man:

That’s right, Richard Ashcroft is BACK – well, actually he was never really away what with the Verve reunion and his own solo project…. but that defies the point which is: do we really need Richard Ashcroft to be back? This is a man who lives in the shadow of “Bittersweet Symphony” and claims to be constantly trying to break free from the fact that it is the Verve’s defining song. Great. Okay, that seems achievable. You don’t need to change your voice to change your tune, so Ashcroft had set out on something very achievable.

But then this happened: he formed this band. This band? Only RPA And The United Nations Of Sound… Oh god. Oh god help us all! For a start, when I first heard that Ashcroft was naming his new band this, I could have died. This may be one of the most overblown and downright pretentious band names I’ve ever heard: it’s a bit like saying, “hey we’re under one roof here but the boss is definitely Richard Ashcroft (RPA) and he’s running the show, so let’s ignore the fact that we could have had an interesting world music project and revert to a bit of Bitter Sweet Symphony!”

Wanna know what it sounds like? You sure? Okay:

Oh dear, where to start? I suppose this is meant to be rousing, and heart-warming but… it falls so short. So short that it kind of does the opposite… Those drums, for a start, are overpowering and uninspired, the guitar that seeps in every now and then is cheesy and smacks a little of the 80s (bad 80s, not sophisticated 80s revival), Ashcroft’s voice breaks under the strain of holding a single note, there’s a chant at the end that’s a hideously blatant attempt at audience participation (for the record, audience participation is a thing of beauty when the crowd does it off their own back, but when forced it crumbles and seems cheesy) and then there’s the strings….

The strings… they’re so Bitter Sweet Symphony! Argh! It’s all gone the shape of the pear!

Ashcroft should have done the noble thing and bowed out a couple of years ago after the Verve reformed. Let’s face it, reformations can only mean one of two things: either you’re an old band who’s running out of money or you’re a relatively new band who are trying to cling desperately to the feelings of the glory days. Ashcroft falls dinstinctly into the latter, and it would have been nice if he didn’t try to leech off the popularity of the older stuff.

Here’s where Noel Gallagher comes in (bear with me). On the release of “TIme Flies”, Oasis’ greatest hits record, Gallagher claimed that it didn’t make sense to have the CD go in chronological order, because that would mean “that all the iconic stuff would be at the front” – and that really is Gallagher’s words! Much like what Gallagher says, Ashcroft’s iconic stuff is in the Verve heyday, and everything after that is living in the shadow of the early success, much like Oasis and “Definitely Maybe”. When Oasis split, many said that they hadn’t written a good song since the “Definitely Maybe” days, and Ashcroft will be resigned to the same fate.

Carrying on is okay if you’re a small band, or you’re willing to constantly reinvent yourself, but now is the time for Ashcroft to bow out, before the shadow consumes him and people tell him to give it a rest. Much like I’m doing now.

Advertisements

16 Responses to “Overblown, Stale, Grainy. It Can Only Mean One Thing….”

  1. Todd Pack July 13, 2010 at 1:58 pm #

    I kind of liked the song … until he started singing. Then I had to turn it off. Yikes.

    • oasis July 14, 2010 at 3:39 am #

      I think the same.

  2. cowbrainz July 13, 2010 at 2:01 pm #

    I must be a synaesthete because after listening to that I had to wash the saccharine taste out of my mouth! I’ll bet CBC Radio’s all over this one.

    Um…thanks for sharing? 🙂

    • scarletsculturegarden July 13, 2010 at 2:08 pm #

      Yeah, I had to show the song so that, you know, you could judge for yourself… I guess I was wrong to say that there’d be backlash because all I’ve got so far is like-mindedness!

  3. sayitinasong July 13, 2010 at 8:09 pm #

    Well, I listened to the new stuff and its not that bad! Yes, it is very difficult to move away from the shadow of the bittersweet symphony as it is such an iconic song… bless him for trying though… :o)

  4. greengeekgirl July 13, 2010 at 8:44 pm #

    This song sounds like…. he’s trying to be a cross between what he was, Bruce Springsteen, John Mellancamp… and something else that’s really terrible.

    Is it better to burn out or fade away? I vote for burn out while you’re still hot. 🙂

    • scarletsculturegarden July 14, 2010 at 9:19 am #

      I vote for burn out too – that’s why everyone who died young (Kurt Cobain, Marc Bolan, Jimi Hendrix) are so great, because they never got the opportunity to do anything awful!

  5. Pie July 13, 2010 at 9:58 pm #

    He’s sounding more and more like Bob Geldof (and not in a good way). There are times when you just need to know when to step down gracefully. This could be it.

    By the way, as a long term subscriber to, and occasional commentator on your blog, I must congratulate you on making it to freshly pressed. I also like your new theme. It definitely suits you.

    • scarletsculturegarden July 14, 2010 at 9:18 am #

      Awww thanks Pie, I don’t really know why you haven’t been featured on FP but maybe your time will come soon! And yes, he should step down now before it gets worse!

  6. Pete Brook July 14, 2010 at 7:38 am #

    Terrible. Worse than terrible. Whiney, whiney, whine-whine nasal nonsensical excuse for the type of anthem that went out of fashion 10 years ago. How does this stuff get released? Is there really no-one in Ashcroft’s immediate circle to tell him it is utter pap?

  7. amirafimisr July 14, 2010 at 7:51 am #

    United nations of dum

  8. psychobone July 14, 2010 at 11:06 am #

    It Can Only Mean One Thing… nice!

  9. sarahnsh July 14, 2010 at 3:50 pm #

    The name is what got me, that is too hilarious and I’d say they were spoofing themselves but I guess not, they’re serious, wow.

  10. work from home July 15, 2010 at 5:37 am #

    I am agree with you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: